How do those have an inherent, fixed, no-fiat-needed value but shadow blade does not. All kinds of curses that would make no sensible creature give you money for them. There are magic items which instantly kill you if you attune to them. There are magic items which vanish upon single use. I will maintain that it's exactly as sensible as saying that a magic weapon has no value because it doesn't have one explicitly listed, so for the sake of consistency I'd ask any DM who goes with that reading to not allow those to work either. I can definitely see how this could be interpreted the other way though, and it's really a matter of do you take printed RAW over digital RAW, and that's really a matter for your DM to answer. He agreed with me that the rules seemed to indicate that it was possible, and he would allow it. I presented this exact set of evidence to my DM and asked for his ruling on if my Bladesinger could use blade cantrips using Shadow Blade. As DnD Beyond has been updated since Tasha's was released, this becomes the "most recent published version." RAW are supposed to follow the "most recent published version" of the rule in question. Sage Advice does not specifically address this combination of spells. DnD Beyond lists "a weapon" as a material component. Tasha's, the most recent print publication with the blade cantrips, states a weapon worth more than 1 silver piece is a required component. The determination is best left to your DM. Megathread D&D 5e 1D&D D&D 4e D&D v3.5 D&D 3e Pathfinder 1 Pathfinder 2 WOD PBTA Fate GURPS Universal OtherĪt best the RAW is conflicted on this. r/DnD /r/rpg /r/Pathfinder_RPG /r/tabletop /r/UnearthedArcana /r/DnDHomebrew /r/dndnext Related Non-TTRPG Subreddits r/characterdrawing /r/Imaginar圜haracters /r/alternativeart On-Topic Subreddits Abide by the Homebrew Content Guidelines.Don't just advertise things, even if they're relevant.If your post fits with a megathread, post there.SFW posts should not receive NSFW comments. The rules are explained in more detail here. There's an issue with the sub that moderators cannot solve, this is a workaround for it. If you're trying to post from an app and can't, try from a browser. Message the moderators, it'll be unfiltered if it's on topic. If your account is less than 7 days old or has less than 20 karma, you may be autofiltered. Find help with your new idea, or share your memorable builds. Aid other tabletop gamers in creating interesting or devastating characters.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |